Monthly Rentals in Cayuga Lake

Staying at Mara's house was exactly what we needed to welcome in 2025. The house itself is immaculate, well appointed, comfortable and has incredible lakefront views to tie it all together. Getting around the Cayuga Lake area was so easy from where the house is located and there are even some incredible wineries and breweries minutes away. The layout and setup of the house was very thoughtfully done and everything we needed (and more) was there. 10/10 excellent stay.

We look forward to our stay with Diane and Glen every year. The space is comfortable and clean. The hosts are very responsive and easy to communicate with.

Excellent experience during stay look forward to next stay!

Our stay was fantastic. The property is serene, offering a peaceful retreat with plenty of space to spread out and feel completely at home, whether you’re traveling solo or with a group. What really stood out to us was the level of thoughtfulness in every detail—from the well-stocked kitchen to the cozy corners throughout the house. The highlight for us, traveling with young children (2.5 and 1.5 years old), was the dedicated play area in the living room, filled with toys and books for a wide range of ages. Our little ones were thrilled! On the 2nd day of our stay, a minor hiccup occurred when landscapers unexpectedly arrived at the cottage. We notified the hosts, and they responded immediately, apologizing profusely for the oversight. Not only did they rush over in person to make things right, but they also went out of their way to offer us thoughtful gestures to ensure our stay remained enjoyable. Their genuine care & hospitality made a lasting impression - will be happy to return!