Holiday rentals with a pool in Cayuga Lake

We loved this place!! There was so many amenities that we weren’t able to use because we weren’t in the house a ton as we were in a wedding, but boy did we miss out on them! We had a perfect stay and would absolutely stay again if we were ever in the area again. No complaints at all!

We had an incredible stay at this rental! The indoor pool was absolutely fantastic - a highlight of our trip. Check- in and check-out were seamless, and Neil was wonderful to communicate with - responsive, friendly, and helpful. The location was ideal, with easy access to resturants and groceries. The kitchen was well appointed and had everything we needed to cook meals comfortably. Overall, this rental exceeded our expectations, and we will definitely stay here again. Highly recommend.

Mallory’s place was perfect for three of us visiting the area for a long weekend. Considering the smaller space, all of the everyday amenities were still covered. The place was incredibly clean and this location can’t be beat for nearby drinking establishments and grub. The beds were comfortable, heaters kept the place toasty in January, and there were plenty of thoughtful extras available for us at check-in!

This place was spectacular! Our family had an amazing time. It was everything we wanted and allowed us to focus on making incredible memories together. Thank you for sharing your home with us!

We had a wonderful stay at Scott’s beautiful lakeside home at the Finger Lakes! We stayed for three days to celebrate my wife's birthday, and this serene spot made it truly special. The house is peaceful and perfectly situated by the lake, providing a perfect escape. Scott was incredibly responsive and proactive—he made sure we had all the instructions we needed in advance, and the home was equipped with all the necessary amenities to make our stay comfortable. It was clear he put thought into ensuring a smooth experience for his guests. We highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a relaxing and memorable stay!

We loved the Hobbit House! The space was clean; the design details made the cottage cozy & inviting; the tiled shower was gorgeous. The Hobbit House is nestled into a gorgeous farm setting replete with pigs, chickens, sheep, & horses whom we enjoyed petting—they enjoyed the bag of carrots we brought as a welcome gift. Everyone we met there on the farm was friendly & even though it felt like we were way out in the country, it only took 20 minutes to get back into the heart of Ithaca. Can’t wait to return!

We had a wonderful stay at Eddie’s home! He was very responsive and provided clear instructions for check-in and check-out, making everything seamless. The house was exactly as described—clean, cozy, and well-stocked with everything we needed, including complimentary 1911 canned drinks, travel-sized toiletries, and a fully equipped kitchen. The Peloton bike was a great bonus, especially before our Thanksgiving dinner! The location does require climbing a large hill from Route 20, which we were initially nervous about due to the weather forecast, but the road was well-maintained and it didn’t end up being an issue. The neighborhood was peaceful and the house has stunning views. We can only imagine how beautiful it is in the fall, or how fun the pool would be in warmer months. We’d definitely stay here again, ideally during nicer weather to fully enjoy the outdoor amenities.

Dean and his place are great, our stay was peaceful without any hiccups or surprises, everything was as described and pictures mimiced the listing to a T. We will absolutely return!

Large beautiful house, accommodates for a large family. Kitchen had all you needed to cook and the home had lots of space to spread out. Lots of extras at the home, such as toiletries, cleaning products, laundry soap. etc. Very quiet and private location. Mark was a great host, with prompt replies.