Cabin holiday rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

The house was absolutely beautiful and everything we were looking for for our girls weekend. The heat did stop working and Jonathan was quick to respond and send out their maintenance guy, Rich. All in all great experience!

Sharyn’s house is very beautiful. A great place to get away and just relax. The house was set up perfect to bring the kids, as well as friends/family. All ages had something to do in this house. Sharyn was super responsive and always willing to help if we ever needed. Amazing place and we are very glad we went to this house. Thank you again!

We very much enjoyed our stay at Justin's Airbnb. It had all the comforts of home and more. We loved the garage with all the games and very much appreciated the heated floors! The property is very serene and gave us much needed rest and relaxation. We had the fireplace going every day, and there was plenty of wood, ready to go. We already booked to come back next year! Thank you for a great stay!

This is our third stay and it’s always so incredible, third time! This tiny home overlooking the scenic Mahoning River has become the place my husband and I go to unwind. The mere thought brings my BP down. ME really put a lot of thought into this build, tiny but not lacking anything, high end appointments too.

Beautiful A-frame and a very nice atmosphere in the house to read and relax in! The bed was very comfortable and everything was super clean. The neighborhood is a bit bland, but that doesn’t detract much from the beauty of the home. The non-stick pan didn’t have much nonstick left on it so you may want to bring your own pan. Also if you take a walk down the road take a stick or pepper spray with you cause some of the neighbors down the road a ways have dogs that were not friendly.

I absolutely loved staying at this cabin! It looks just like the photos. Super clean, cozy, warm, and has everything you need for a weekend getaway. The hot tub was perfect. I cant wait to come back!

Beautiful little weekend getaway with access to plenty of great restaurants and outdoor hiking

Absolutely hated to leave this place!! Beautiful home, attentive host, lots of sweet touches, extra pillows and comfy blankets everywhere!! Such a perfect girls getaway!! I hope this home away from home is always booked (except if we get a chance to come back!) Thank you Alissa, from three overworked overwhelmed exhausted service industry besties!!

The cabin was beautiful and peaceful. Super clean, had everything we needed. The location was great we went for bike week. It was great to go back to the cabin at night and not hear the loud sounds of bikes all night. The owners were very responsive. I set the fire alarm off with my blow dryer and I messaged them right away to let them know everything was OK and they got back to me within seconds. I would highly recommend staying here. You can see the beautiful lake from the view of the porch and can even walk down a beautifully constructed set of steps to get closer to the scenery. would absolutely stay again.

This place is a dream! The cabin was better than described. We wanted for nothing! Checking in was seamless. We enjoyed lazy days of reading and fishing and hanging out with our 7 month old and our pup. Winnie left us fully stocked—even firewood for the wood burning stove which we thoroughly enjoyed. It was more than enough to keep us super toasty during our stay. The river and surrounding area was perfect for hiking (plan to use a baby carrier rather than a stroller). The cabin is cozy and spacious too. The kitchen was well stocked and was perfect for cooking a big pot of chili to feast on. There were ample art supplies, books, and games. We sincerely hope that Winnie will have us back again as we can see this cabin becoming a family favorite.

We couldn’t have planned a better weekend getaway. The grounds were beautiful. The cabin was clean and comfortable. Leigh and Matt are friendly and accommodating hosts who wanted us to have the best experience they could offer and they met every expectation we could have imagined. We will be recommending Bison Trace to all of our friends!! Thank you for a great weekend!!

This is my second stay at Molly’s cabin —- highly recommend! The cabin is clean, safe, and in a beautiful location. Molly is a great host! (There was bad winter weather during my stay. Molly proactively communicated with me throughout my whole stay, making accommodations with check-in and check-out.) Again, highly recommended staying here!

We have stayed in the past and plan on making it a regular stop when in town to visit family. Great brewery and restaurant about 5 minutes down the street and enjoyed a fire in the back when we returned.

Multiple stays here. Always peaceful and tranquil. Michelle is friendly, responsive, and her breakfasts are amazing l!

great communication, very friendly and helpful. I would recommend this to family and friends.

Nice view of the lake from the front porch. There are several cabins in a very quiet and well kept area. We plan on returning when the weather is nicer. The hosts are very responsive and there is plenty to do nearby. The cabin is super cute with all the amenities!

Very peaceful and cozy, would definitely stay again and recommend to other

Absolutely perfect property and host. Impossible to imagine how anything could be better. The house itself is immaculate and the backyard is beautiful. We will definitely return.

My family and I were so pleased with our stay. It was clean and private and just as described. The beds were comfortable. Gwendolyn was super responsive and friendly. The location was wonderful. The kids enjoyed exploring the surroundings. We loved it so much that we booked it again for the summer and are already looking forward to our return.

my husband and i were so impressed with the entire place and location. it was very peaceful. the bed was extremely comfortable. we felt very comfortable in entire place. Scott provided coffee and local chocolate! it was above and beyond. great stay!

Best air b and b I have ever stayed at! The hosts are amazing! Such a peaceful and welcoming and friendly atmosphere! The land around it itself is like stepping into a story of gorgeous land and friendly people and amazing animals. Beautiful scenery, with tranquil ponds. Truly worth every penny!

This place was beautiful for a weekend get away. We enjoyed exploring the trails and sitting on the deck and enjoying the peace and quiet. Very much worth the money and then some.

Overall our stay was perfect! As described and no run in with any insects/creatures. Checking in was very easy! They also went out of their way and left a little surprise in the fridge for my mother for her birthday. So thoughtful. I give 10/10 rating and would totally come back to stay if in the area again. Thank you Tony for a fantastic weekend getaway!

This was a comfy cabin off the beaten path. The host was incredible and everything matched the description. We had a great stay and would gladly stay here again the next time we're visiting.