Holiday houses in Sugar Loaf Cay

Mermaid Cottage is the Gold Standard that all Airbnbs should strive for…the very best..not just for the location which is stunning. Very well appointed, spectacularly clean and the bed and linens were perfection! Roland the caretaker is beyond attentive and a genuine sweetheart! The owners Brandon and Lucy have done an outstanding job with their property and are excellent at communicating! We can’t wait to return!

I had a wonderfully relaxing month at the Beach Villa gated community in Tanae’s well equipped home. The only thing I had to buy was a wine bottle opener! :) The house was so conveniently located within a one minute walk from a pool that was consistently heated to 86 degrees F or higher, and one of the top ten beaches in the world - with an amazing sand bar within a 25 minute walk. The gated community offered some great facilities including reverse osmosis purified water that could be purchased at an affordable price, token operated washers and dryers, and periodic catered or potluck pool parties that ensured plenty of opportunity to mix and mingle. Nearby, there are some great places to eat including the bakery directly across the street from Tanae’s place, the Bahamas Beach Club beach bar, Sunset Pizza and also nightly entertainment from Wed through Sun at Coops on the main highway. This was a super place to stay on my first trip back following Hurricane Dorian. :)

The location's great! Can walk to Cafe la Florence, a gift shop, convenience store, and the harbor where you can meet up with Captain Mark, for day excursions. 5 minute walk to the pool, and 30 steps to one of the most beautiful beaches we had ever seen! Villas are beautiful, but very close together. If people had been in the yellow one, next door, it may have felt a little crowded, as there is no landscaping between them. The day before we left, very loud work was done on an outside wall without any notice, which kinda surprised us. The villa was very clean, had clean, comfortable sheets & spreads, and had most things we needed. The livingroom TV was dying. The grill was VERY dirty with no brush to clean it, but we burned off as much as possible to grill one night. Could have used a few more beach towels, as there were only 5, with 4 of us staying a week, but we had plenty of bath towels. It was a decent, comfortable stay even with those few negatives, because.... OMG, THAT BEACH! 🥰

Highly recommend! Greet with a pleasant experience, communication skills is excellent. I will definitely book for every visit. Love it!!

Bev & Jim's BnB is fantastic! The kitchen has a ton of amenities and the BnB is centrally located so you're no more than 5 to 10 minutes away from everything by golf cart. Very short walk to a nice beach and beautiful views of the Atlantic. We hope to visit again soon!

Maranatha cottage is a very comfortable and picturesque Loyalist saltbox cottage. It has great views on both floors. It has all the amenities one can need. It is very conveniently located with all the town sites in proximity. My kids loved playing basketball with the locals at a nearby town basketball court. It was wonderful to walk in the mornings to the bakery by the dock for a loaf of freshly baked bread. Our host, Jennie, was very caring, she met us at the ferry and arranged for delivery of a golf cart. The house is well equipped for an occasional power outage, with lanterns, powerful fans that work during outage and the layout of the house that takes good advantage of the sea breeze on both floors.

This is our 3rd stay at Lo Key Villa and it did not disappoint! The separate upper and lower levels are perfect for a group trip (especially with kids). The space is clean, AC and fans worked well, and we felt safe. The washer/dryer worked and felt clean. The kitchen has enough supplies (and a great blender). The host, James, was responsive and helpful too! The proximity to CocoBay is insane - instant activities for kiddos or relaxing away from the excitement of feeding turtles and stingrays. We loved taking out the kayaks for a peaceful adventure. This home will always have a special place in our hearts. Can’t wait to return!

Nice place close to the beach and very clean. The shampoo, conditioner, and body soap were all great quality and everything was very clean. The beds are very comfortable. Would highly recommend.

Wonderful stay, very clean, comfortable. Loved that it was so close to the beach. One suggestion would be to provide a wine corkscrew. But overall we had a great time.