Apartment holiday rentals in Shirley

I really liked the place

We really enjoyed our stay, everything from the living room to the kitchen to the bathroom to the bedroom was simply amazing. A very peaceful and private place which really helped with the relaxation during our stay.

The place was very clean and very quiet. Great location right between NYC and eastern Long Island. Very easy to find and very reasonably priced. The host was easy to communicate with and very welcoming and polite. My wife, kids and myself had a great weekend and would definitely stay again.

Kimberly’s place is fabulous. The location cannot be beat - you’re close to everything yet have the peace of a quiet street. The apartment is well appointed and impeccably clean. The instructions are very clear with lots of suggestions for great things to do. I hope to stay here again.

Thank you for another great stay in your wonderful home! Always so quiet, clean and great for close proximity to stores, restaurants and train. We will be back!

Joanne greeted us when we arrived - wanted to make sure we were comfortable. She encouraged us to contact her with any questions. The apartment was clean, well equipped and spacious. We are native Long Islanders and this location was central to the family and friends we were visiting.

Lovely and comfortable space. Easy drive to Babylon Village restaurants and amenities.

What a wonderful week. Paul was so great and so helpful. Check-in was easy, and the apartment was exactly what I was looking for. It was the perfect place to relax, but also have a great time on Fire Island. And it so nice to have a spot I could bring my dog with me. I'm defiantly going to keep an eye out for future availability.

Damian’s apartment is exactly like it’s advertised to be. I’ve stayed here several times when available, and will stay again. Damian is a top host. Easily accessible, always available to help. Don’t hesitate, if it’s available, grab it.

Really impressed with the attentiveness of the staff. My only callout is expect to be surrounded by other guests, especially at the communal spaces outside – table, grill, etc. We overlapped with two different friend groups staying in a few of the properties, but everyone was really respectful and quiet. Just close quarters!

Great stay! Would love to go back

Andrea’s place was a great find. We were in town visiting some family and the location was perfect. The place was very easy to find which was helpful for our late night arrival. It was very cozy and had all the amenities for our week-long stay. The warm decor was very pleasant. Andrea was friendly and communicative. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a place in Long Island!

Exactly as described. Very well kept. A cozy little place with great furnishings. Felt right at home. Martin was great. He was outside when I pulled up and showed me around. Super nice host. A great experience all around!

Kettly and Peter's place is clean, peaceful, and private -- the suite has a separate outer staircase and entrance. We enjoyed being able to come and go without disrupting the owners. Kettly and Peter were gracious to receive our two Amazon packages during our stay. We highly recommend their place for its location. It was close to the village of Wading River, the local beach, and several historical sites. Several wonderful restaurant options were a short drive away. Wildwood State Park is within 15 minutes by car and well worth a visit; likewise for the North Fork communities located farther East on the Island. BTW, the Fall scenery and local wildlife (i.e., wild turkey, white-tail deer, and pheasant) were abundant and delightfully unexpected. We highly recommend Kettly and Peter's place as a comfortable base -- Thanks, Kettly and Peter! We'll book again on our next trip to LI!

Had a very nice stay, everything was just like the pictures. Everything was clean and sanitary. Host was very responsive. Would definitely stay again.

We stayed there during the Christmas holidays to spend time with our son, who moved there recently. It was a nice visit and even though this place was a tad bit small but perfect for what we needed. Our daughter had a room for herself but still within the same space with us, like a 2 bedroom suite. Better than staying at a hotel. Our only complaint is that the climate control system could be improved. It was very warm at 72°C even though it was set by the host to 68°F.

I looooove this spot. It’s my second time staying, but the first time as the person booking the Airbnb, and it was exactly the same as last year. So well-maintained, with a gorgeous private back yard and perfectly hot hot tub! Just a 7-8 minute walk to the Ferry, 2 minute walk to the beach, and a 20 minute walk to the middle of the Pines. The couch in the living room pulls out into a bed, which was perfect for rainy-day movie time! Verrrry cold AC, soft comfy beds, and extra sheets. Also love the outdoor shower that gets hot incredibly quickly. We had an issue with a broken appliance and the hosts responded to our message within literally a minute. So lovely to chat with, so helpful and friendly! I hope I get the chance to stay a third time!

I have stayed at Firefly multiple times and always come back for the same reasons: the home is cozy, clean, great location, all the supplies and amenities you need in a special community. The hosts are responsive and easy to coordinate with. I love this charming beach home.

We had a wonderful Valentine's day Weekend at Deborah's. The loft was so cozy and so cute. She allowed us to bring our cat (who also had a blast sleeping in the cozy beds). The hot tub was also super relaxing and Deborah was nice enough to put an orange tarp on top of the tub so it can be a bit covered from the snow (which by the way, super unserious suggestion, a roof over the tub would be amazing). We also enjoyed how close it was to Sag Harbor and some other Vineyards we were able to visit. The property itself was also super peaceful, it was an overall relaxing weekend. Thank you for being such a great host!

Very quiet and peaceful apartment. We stayed for a week and we felt very much at home. Lots to watch on the tv, the loveseat is very comfortable, great shower and had all the amenities as described. Perfect for 2 people. Will definitely stay again next time we’re in town.

This apartment is in the top 1% for a reason. We had a wonderful stay. The apartment has a great layout, clean and feels welcoming. The bed is comfy. The hosts provide items in the apartment which are so thoughtful and attentive. In addition, they were responsive, friendly and gave recommendations for places to visit and eat. We look forward in visiting again!

well,the place was very clean, cozy and private. Host very friendly I would recommend this place to anyone who wants to spend some time as a getaway.

I had the best time I’ve ever had at Fire Island Pines, thanks to Alan and Ethan and their beautiful home. We loved the Poolhouse - it was incredibly comfortable, well-looked after, had beautiful amenities, and had the flexibility of being both a place to gather and a place of rest and privacy. Great kitchen and bathroom, comfortable bedroom. Alan and Ethan were welcoming, generous and charming hosts, who made us feel very special and part of the family. I can’t wait to go back!

This place was one of the best Airbnb experiences I’ve ever had. I’m part of a group of engineering students who came to Connecticut to participate in a robotics competition— this place was amazing. There was a bunch of room for us to move around, many beds, a great kitchen, and an awesome hot tub. The host was super helpful, responsive, and kind. If I ever come back to Connecticut, I’ll highly consider checking this place out again— seriously great.