Holiday rentals with a patio in Shelter Island Heights

Cute place, ideal for a couple. Location was perfect, next to coffeehouses, restaurants and bars and a short walk to the water. Most definitely will stay here again.

Great location. Right next to cherry blossoms and the famous pizza spots. Comfy beds

We stayed here for 6 days and it was the perfect spot! She had everything we needed & it was a beautiful place to spend our vacation. Erica was extremely responsive whenever we had questions for her. We would definitely come stay here again!!

Great place with lovely accommodation

We enjoyed our stay at Samantha and Robert’s place. Convenient location, close to downtown and the beach. The place is spacious and cozy. Samantha and Robert provided us with everything we needed.

Sabrina's place was lovely. She made excellent use if the space and creative an environment that was clean and inviting. It was a bit cool when I was there but her outdoor space is well manicured and thoughtfully developed. I would highly recommend her place to any and all who plan to visit New Haven

Terrific spot…tucked away and peaceful. Walkable to local establishments. The room is large enough for two and has everything you need for a weekend stay!

A perfect spot for our wedding weekend get-away. Clean!! The most important detail for us is the cleanliness. Nothing was missed. We’d come back in a heartbeat.

We had a wonderful stay! Clean, comfortable and easily located to all. We will deff be back soon!

Aida’s house is very nice place to stay for a getaway in the Hamptons. Amazing outdoor area. Great for traveling with kids. Aida is a great host!

We loved our stay at Deborah and David's home. The house was perfect for our family, so clean and well equipped. It is even better than on the photos. And what an amazing backyard for the kids!

It was wonderful stay and I’d go back anytime

Really liked this house - quiet and secluded with the family. Good amenities, lovely back yard, and peaceful surroundings. About 20 mins to the beach by the time you park and walk across. A 10-15 min walk to a little dock with a playground for young kids. Thanks for the stay!

A very comfortable place for a large group to stay. We had 9 and everyone had a comfortable bed with only one couple sharing a massive (california?) king sized bed. Well stocked kitchen with plenty of plates and glassware. (As always with any house rental, if you want to cook, bring your own knives). Huge dining table fit us all with room to spare. Kitchen was plenty big enough for everyone to hang out in while breakfast was being made by 2-3 people. Convenient off street parking. Easy on off to the highway. Very clear instructions on how to get in. This is a large, three storey home that's been nicely touched up and improved. The wood floors are beautifully redone--what look to be original wood floors. The bathrooms are updated, spacious and clean. The place was spotless, uncluttered, and the perfect temperature when we arrived.

We needed a dog-friendly ranch style to home with three bedrooms and two bedrooms close to Sayville, where we would be celebrating Thanksgiving. I was lucky enough to find this rental which was clean, comfortable and ideal for our two-night stay. Adam was attentive and easily accessible via text. I would highly recommend this lovely home.

We planned a moms weekend away at Chris’ house and the accommodations were great! Easily fit 8 women comfortably. The only issue was figuring out the heat (it was a fancy thermostat) and definitely could have used a larger coffee pot and more mugs for the amount of people. Otherwise, all good and we would definitely consider booking again!

Great place, exactly as advertised. Terrific location near ferry dock (making arrival/check-in extremely easy and fast, which was a relief after a long trip to get to Fire Island), near the little main hub of Cherry Grove… minutes or less to the general store, restaurants, bars. 5 minute walk to the beach. Although there is some bar noise at night, the unit is well sound-insulated. Hosts extremely friendly and communicative, full of info and recommendations. They take pride in their place and in being great hosts. Cozy place with very good value for Fire Island. The pool was a nice plus - salt water pool, lit at night. Met some of the other residents in the building who were extremely friendly and fun. Bed was very comfy. We slept in a lot. Wi-Fi worked perfectly. Nice desk in the bedroom for the few times work called. Roku TV. Lots of board games Bedroom has AC which worked great. Beach chairs and towels included. Coin laundry on site worked well. Great value. Would definitely return!

We had a pleasant stay at Nick’s place. The unit was comfortable and clean. The location was perfect with a beautiful view of the water & restaurants in walking distance. Check-in was very easy and Nick was always responsive.

We really enjoyed staying at Lynn’s place! Very clean and had a great view of the ocean from the deck. Lynn was very responsive and made the experience seamless. We would definitely stay with Lynn again.

Thanks Lauren! We enjoyed your lovely place!

Had a wonderful stay with my family. Clean, comfortable, great location. Good communication. Had a little trouble with the front door first day but someone was available quickly to help. A+

Tara’s place was a perfect for a weekend getaway! Close enough to town and great view of the sunset!

Great place to stay in Sag Harbor!