Holiday rentals with a fire pit in Penn Yan

My family of two adults and one 4 year old stayed at Teresa’s while visiting family for the holidays and it was a great place. It’s well and thoughtfully stocked, and was beautifully decorated for the holidays. The porch was very helpful for having Wegmans groceries delivered. It was plenty warm enough for us Californians in December, and Teresa responded right away when our jet lagged brains couldn’t find the toaster (it’s in the lazy Susan). Would definitely stay here again, and highly recommend it.

If I’d really read the check in directions and not just the address finding the house would have been very clear! The house is on an auto repair shop property but it didn’t bother us a bit! The bed was very comfortable and the set up of kitchen and living/dining area just perfect. The faucet in the tub is lose and should probably be checked. Water supply and temp were great. We even enjoyed the spacious porch to watch the morning sky and birds, in spite of chilly weather! The house met our needs perfectly! We’d happily return.

Barb was extremely helpful and her place was great. We really liked the location of her house and the neighborhood. The town is really close by and Barb had helped us with local recommendations. The house was nice and cozy and her backyard is beautiful with a little stream running just behind. Would recommend.

I enjoyed a terrific, albeit brief, stay at Joan's cottage. She was very proactive in her communication, making everything a breeze from check-in to departure. The place itself is very thoughtfully appointed, with lots of appreciated details. It was charming and cozy, and located ideally for my taste: an easy drive into town, right near the lake, and quiet and private. I would absolutely return in the future.

I had a wonderful 3-night stay at this cozy cabin. The location was perfect for a peaceful getaway, surrounded by nature. The cabin itself was clean, well-equipped, and had a charming rustic feel. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a great spot close to Watkins Glen and area!

We had a great time hiking the area! The house was super cute! A lot of the house is brand new. One of the cleanest Airbnbs I’ve ever stayed at!! Lots of coffee & Tea, along with snacks included! Also supplied all the fire wood we could possibly need for a camp fire!! Our Golden retriever enjoyed laying in the sunshine watching the cows in the adjacent pasture! Would highly recommend this place!

Chelsey offers a nice place in a great location on a quiet street. She was very helpful and quick to reply to questions. I would definitely come back. Thanks!

Jason was a wonderful host. The one and only time I reached out, he responded immediately. He also provided many suggestions for local restaurants, hiking spots and other nearby locations of interest. The home itself is lovely and sits on a beautiful piece of property. (The photos don't do it justice). It was exactly what we were looking for.

Our second time here and we look forward to returning. It is peaceful, cozy, has all comforts of home and is surrounded by great backyard with walking trails that are beautiful. We definitely recommend.

It was a perfect place to stay for our mother & daughter weekend exploring Watkins Glenn and surrounding area(waterfalls, hiking, wineries, breweries, lakes).Can easily walk into town to shops, restaurants and WG state park. Apartment is fully stocked with all needed for our stay. It is a super cozy, comfortable & clean. Host is very helpful & responsive. It was a perfect fall getaway. Hope to return in the future.

I recently had the pleasure of staying at Don's Airbnb, and it was a fantastic experience from start to finish! Don went above and beyond to ensure my stay was comfortable and enjoyable. Communication with Don was seamless. He was quick to respond to any questions i had and provided recommendation to local restaurants, spas, museums etc.

Glenn and Diana’s place is a must stay!!!! The space was so cozy, clean, and comfortable. The sunsets over the lake are enchanting, and stargazing at night is incredible. Additionally, Glenn and Diana provided great recommendations for wineries, breweries, food, and activities in the area.

This space was PERFECT for our little anniversary getaway in the finger lakes! Ron was very responsive and we loved all of the treats he supplied the house with. We can wait to come back during the summer! Thank you, Ron!

Mary is a lovely host and the space is very cozy! Thank you for your kindness and warm welcome

We enjoyed being able to come and go while taking in the historical and cultural offerings of Auburn. We’ll be back!

Thankful I was able to book a last minute stay here with my dog and felt comfortable and safe. Would stay again.

Very enjoyable weekend at this home. Quiet and relaxing. Deserves the great reviews it gets. Will visit again.

This place turned out to be exactly what we were looking for and needed! A cozy cabin with plenty of space for three people to spread out (and easily room for a few more) for a calm winter getaway. We made almost all our meals there throughout the week, and the kitchen has about everything one would need. Bathroom is nice, new shower appreciated as well as the heated tile floor. Bedroom and beds upstairs feel new and the mattresses are quite firm, so a great nights sleep for us. The propane fireplace was perfect! both ambient & effective The property is massive and the trails made for nice little daily adventures. Snow on the ground and the pond was frozen, so we got a couple days of ice time before rising temps made it a bit too wet. Feels very remote on-property, especially at night, but there are a couple cute towns 20 minutes east or west. Leila diner and Naples pizza highlights. The owner, Felicia, is very responsive and nice to interact with. We hope to be back someday!

This cabin was a great and beautiful time, in a very nice town. Very private and the host is easy to contact with clear instructions. Definitely recommend and hope return another time!

Nancy’s cottage was perfect for our little family of 4. We enjoyed card games on the back porch, meals al fresco w a beautiful lake view, and of course roasting marshmallows in the fire pit at sunset. The cottage was intimate and cozy and we hope to return on a regular basis. Thank you Nancy for being inviting and more than accommodating.

A great private little cabin in the woods, plenty of wildlife to see, warm and cozy fireplace. Close to many of the Wineries, Breweries and Distilleries.

This is the perfect stay for hiking nearby state parks of New York and winery hopping on the wine trail! Amber’s cabin was clean, cozy, and a great location for everything we wanted to do. Although the cabin does have limited amenities, the bed was comfy to sleep in and the mini-fridge was a savior! We used the bonfire outside, which did have chairs provided, and it was so peaceful and homey. Both of us felt very safe and secluded in this cabin. The walk to the bathroom/shower is short and clean! Both Watkins Glen and Buttermilk State Parks are a 30 minute drive and Taughannock State Park is a 15 minute drive from this spot. There are TONS of wineries anywhere from 5-30 minutes away, which is perfect for hopping! Amber was a great host because she was responsive and provided us first timers to the finger lakes some recommendations that we tried and were not disappointed in! Overall, we highly recommend Amber and her cabin. If we ever go back, we would definitely stay here again! :)

I have stayed in several AirBNBs in the Penn Yan area over the last six months, and this one was my favorite. I especially loved the location: on a hill looking over the lake, with lake access, but still in the woods. Wonderful place to spend a cozy weekend.

Our group celebrated a bachelor party here. We had a great time.