Holiday rentals with outdoor seating in Baiting Hollow

"Our stay with Emily & Henry was absolutely wonderful! The space was beautifully designed with tasteful interior decor that made us feel both comfortable and luxurious. The rooms were remarkably spacious, allowing us to truly relax and unwind during our visit. What really stood out was the exceptional communication from our hosts. Emily and Henry were incredibly responsive, answering all our questions almost immediately and ensuring we had everything we needed throughout our stay. Their attentiveness made us feel truly cared for as guests. The property's thoughtful layout and attention to detail impressed us at every turn. From the well-appointed kitchen to the comfortable living spaces, everything was carefully considered to create a welcoming atmosphere. The cleanliness was impeccable, and all amenities were in perfect working order.

Maher’s house was an amazing peaceful experience. I enjoyed my time there and he had great recommendations to restaurants and activities! He was very responsive with all questions we had. I will totally stay here in the future if I can get the chance again!! Thank you Maher!!

Our family opted for a trip to New London to reconnect with our family for Thanksgiving. We were able to utilize the beautiful dining room for our dinner . We loved staying at Rosa’s place and were very comfortable . Just a note - there is only one bathroom and it is on the second floor ( as are all the bedrooms) We made this work but can be difficult with a larger family . It would definitely not deter me from booking again! This place was beautiful. The surrounding area and ease of access was comforting ! Would definitely stay here again .

Perfect weekend getaway spot with a wonderful backyard. The hot tub was a treat and the rooms were clean and spacious. Highly recommend!

This house was fantastic! We cooked a full Thanksgiving dinner here! The house was well stocked with everything we needed, from kitchen essentials to paper products. The layout of the house was great. Jane was very accommodating and made things easy for us! The house was immaculate and met all of our needs. I hope it’s available next Thanksgiving! Perfect location! Close to town, yet quiet and private! It was my granddaughter’s first Thanksgiving and I’m so glad we had this house to celebrate in!

We loved the space! Very clean, and the pool was exactly as pictured. Sandra was responsive with any questions I had and would book with her again in future!

Our family spent a lovely weekend at Anne’s cottage. It was charming, comfortable and exactly as pictured. Communication was timely and thoughtful. The close proximity to the beach makes this location extra special and we appreciated the availability of off street parking. We would not hesitate to book again!

We loved our stay in Westbrook! Mia's lovely home exceeded our expectations in terms of decor, furnishings, cleanliness, comfortable beds, and well-stocked kitchen and bath ... all in a quiet and private setting. The house was especially well-situated for us. We had tickets for a special theater performance at Gillette Castle one evening, and then had to be in New Haven on the next day. All were easy drives. And, there are amazing fine dining options nearby. We'll definitely try to book this wonderful place any time we have events in the area. Thank you, Mia, for a magical Autumn weekend in Connecticut!

No problems at all. Very easy and carefree stay!

Edward is very accommodating! This is my third time stating here, it is my go to place when I visit Long Island!

Our stay was amazing! The views from the balcony were so beautiful and the place looked just like how it did in the pictures. Everything was up to date and easy to use. The host was very responsive and checked in to make sure everything was working good. Would definitely stay here again!

Our 3 time staying at Amanda’s home. Beautiful and spacious within walking distance to village. Looking forward to coming back next year!

Great spot! Very walkable. It's also a great layout if traveling with small children - there is a separate meditation room upstairs that was perfect for setting up our travel cribs. Would stay again!

The place that I stayed in was very nice and clean. I loved it. The neighborhood was very quiet and calm. I definitely enjoyed it and also looking forward to coming back next if I’m ever around the area.

Had an absolutely wonderful stay! Location is perfect and Jaime was incredibly friendly throughout!! He let me know that they had everything we would need.. but as a self-described obsessive packer I didnt listen. He wasn't kiding! They had beach chairs, umbrellas, and everything else you need for the perfect beach day. I brought an entire wagon of stuff and used one bag. It really is an awesome little find!!

well,the place was very clean, cozy and private. Host very friendly I would recommend this place to anyone who wants to spend some time as a getaway.

Great place, exactly as advertised. Terrific location near ferry dock (making arrival/check-in extremely easy and fast, which was a relief after a long trip to get to Fire Island), near the little main hub of Cherry Grove… minutes or less to the general store, restaurants, bars. 5 minute walk to the beach. Although there is some bar noise at night, the unit is well sound-insulated. Hosts extremely friendly and communicative, full of info and recommendations. They take pride in their place and in being great hosts. Cozy place with very good value for Fire Island. The pool was a nice plus - salt water pool, lit at night. Met some of the other residents in the building who were extremely friendly and fun. Bed was very comfy. We slept in a lot. Wi-Fi worked perfectly. Nice desk in the bedroom for the few times work called. Roku TV. Lots of board games Bedroom has AC which worked great. Beach chairs and towels included. Coin laundry on site worked well. Great value. Would definitely return!

This was the perfect last-minute getaway for my always on-the-go family in need of some quiet bonding time. The condo was simple and clean, the beach beautiful (even in the winter), and Alice and Gasper were very responsive. Would highly recommend!

Nice place to stay, close to the main highway.

Lovely stay in greenport! Short drive from major north fork activities. Can imagine its even better during the busy season!

Thanks Lauren! We enjoyed your lovely place!

Such a beautiful condo by the water! Too bad we stayed in November, we would have enjoyed the terrace way more! Mia was so responsive and helpful with my questions prior to the weekend at her place.

I stayed here for a month. The apartment was VERY clean when I came. Had everything I needed. It felt like home. Nicole is EXTREMELY responsive and constantly made sure I did not need anything. There is a ton of great food nearby and very walkable area. As listed, there is no elevator so there are quite a bit of stairs. But not terrible. Overall highly recommend this apartment.

The space is adorable, and we loved the history of the rental and the community. The location was perfect for us—close to everything and secluded all at the same time. Also Jeff is an amazing host and made us feel welcome/at home. The next time we have to head to NY for a family visit we will definitely try to stay here again.