Holiday rentals with outdoor seating in Baiting Hollow

It was a lovely stay. Great location. House felt like a home and had great vibes.

We loved our stay at Deborah and David's home. The house was perfect for our family, so clean and well equipped. It is even better than on the photos. And what an amazing backyard for the kids!

Our book club group thoroughly enjoyed our stay here! The home was beautiful and everything was spotless. Everything was as advertised. Beds were very comfortable.

Maher’s house was an amazing peaceful experience. I enjoyed my time there and he had great recommendations to restaurants and activities! He was very responsive with all questions we had. I will totally stay here in the future if I can get the chance again!! Thank you Maher!!

Amazing stay defiantly recommend to anyone

House is perfect. We stayed for a long weekend over Thanksgiving. Perfect location, beds are comfy, fireplace is cozy and host is very responsive and kind.

This was by far the best place I’ve stayed in. The home was beautiful, clean and spacious. Robin was an excellent hostess.

Had a really nice short stay! Anne was responsive and gave clear instructions, and the place was perfect for us and our 3.5 year old. We came for a family visit but this would be perfect for a little beachy getaway as well. Upstairs mattress was super comfy as a bonus!

Booked this for my mom visiting from the South , perfect location very close to shops and restaurants. The rental was clean and the host was very friendly and accommodating. Will definitely book again

It was a great stay. I found the location perfect, and the place very clean. My host was very quick to respond. everything was very good...

The place was very clean and very quiet. Great location right between NYC and eastern Long Island. Very easy to find and very reasonably priced. The host was easy to communicate with and very welcoming and polite. My wife, kids and myself had a great weekend and would definitely stay again.

Our 3 time staying at Amanda’s home. Beautiful and spacious within walking distance to village. Looking forward to coming back next year!

Great spot! Very walkable. It's also a great layout if traveling with small children - there is a separate meditation room upstairs that was perfect for setting up our travel cribs. Would stay again!

I was looking for a place to book on short notice and Rosa Maria gladly opened up her stay for me! She was very quick with responses and very helpful. 10/10 stay!

Had an absolutely wonderful stay! Location is perfect and Jaime was incredibly friendly throughout!! He let me know that they had everything we would need.. but as a self-described obsessive packer I didnt listen. He wasn't kiding! They had beach chairs, umbrellas, and everything else you need for the perfect beach day. I brought an entire wagon of stuff and used one bag. It really is an awesome little find!!

The whole experience was perfect. There were even fresh flowers to greet me. The location is easy, a beautiful neighborhood that is very quiet and safe. I'm ready to return!

Great place, exactly as advertised. Terrific location near ferry dock (making arrival/check-in extremely easy and fast, which was a relief after a long trip to get to Fire Island), near the little main hub of Cherry Grove… minutes or less to the general store, restaurants, bars. 5 minute walk to the beach. Although there is some bar noise at night, the unit is well sound-insulated. Hosts extremely friendly and communicative, full of info and recommendations. They take pride in their place and in being great hosts. Cozy place with very good value for Fire Island. The pool was a nice plus - salt water pool, lit at night. Met some of the other residents in the building who were extremely friendly and fun. Bed was very comfy. We slept in a lot. Wi-Fi worked perfectly. Nice desk in the bedroom for the few times work called. Roku TV. Lots of board games Bedroom has AC which worked great. Beach chairs and towels included. Coin laundry on site worked well. Great value. Would definitely return!

This was the perfect last-minute getaway for my always on-the-go family in need of some quiet bonding time. The condo was simple and clean, the beach beautiful (even in the winter), and Alice and Gasper were very responsive. Would highly recommend!

Daniel was a blessing, I was in a jam and he not only helped me out but he did it without breaking the bank.

We had an amazing stay! We stayed off peak season, although alot was closed we felt right at home and were more than happy to spend family time at this condo! The views were stunning, and the condo was immaculate. We were close to everything and was still within very reasonable driving distance to the surrounding towns. Julie was a pleasure to work with and was always very responsive and accomadating throughout the process. Hoping to stay again next year!

Such a beautiful condo by the water! Too bad we stayed in November, we would have enjoyed the terrace way more! Mia was so responsive and helpful with my questions prior to the weekend at her place.

Thanks Lauren! We enjoyed your lovely place!

Had a wonderful stay with my family. Clean, comfortable, great location. Good communication. Had a little trouble with the front door first day but someone was available quickly to help. A+

The space is adorable, and we loved the history of the rental and the community. The location was perfect for us—close to everything and secluded all at the same time. Also Jeff is an amazing host and made us feel welcome/at home. The next time we have to head to NY for a family visit we will definitely try to stay here again.